Lawsuit Claims House Candidate Highfill Disfigured University of Iowa Roommate, Brandished Shotgun

A trial date has been set for the lawsuit, which claims Jake Highfill caused a nine-inch gash to the face of his University of Iowa roommate, Carson Kness.

A lawsuit filed against Iowa House District 39 Republican nominee  claims that he brought a shotgun to a college party, argued with his roommate during the event and smashed a glass bottle across the man's face, permanently disfiguring him.

Highfill denies any wrongdoing.

The lawsuit filed in Polk County District Court claims Highfill assaulted his roommate and lifelong friend, Carson Kness, at the University of Iowa by striking him with a glass bottle.

Kness, also a Johnston resident, seeks monetary damages for past and future medical recovery, physical and mental pain and suffering, permanent disfigurement, permanent disability, lost wages and miscellaneous out-of-pocket expenses. Trial is set for Jan. 28, 2013. The lawsuit was filed last year, on Oct. 13.

The lawsuit alleges that during a house party in Iowa City on Oct. 16, 2010, Highfill caused permanent disfiguration of Kness's cheek. 

Highfill, when contacted by Patch Thursday, said he could not comment on the case, but his attorney denied the allegations. In court papers he has said any actions he took were in self-defense.

The 22-year-old Highfill won the Republican primary this month for the newly redistricted House 39 seat, which covers Johnston, Grimes and a portion of rural Polk County west of Saylorville Lake.

Prefer to get your news headlines through Facebook? Like Johnston Patch on Facebook!

In court documents filed in November 2011 by Highfill's lawyer, Sarah Franklin, he denies Kness's allegations.

Highfill claimed in court documents that the party took place in October 2009. He stated that "any actions taken by the defendant were done in self-defense."

In a statement to Patch, his attorney, Sarah Franklin, said: "This lawsuit stems from an unfortunate series of events at a social function. Jake Highfill denies any wrongdoing; Jake was reacting in self-defense and no criminal charges were filed. Jake strongly denies the allegations made in the petition and is vigorously defending the lawsuit."

Kness claims that Highfill appeared downstairs among guests carrying a shotgun. Kness did not know if the gun was loaded, but asked Highfill to secure the gun in a safe location away from guests.

Words were exchanged and ultimately Kness was struck by Highfill with a glass bottle across the left cheek, according to the lawsuit.

Steve Banks, of Banks Law Firm LLC in Waukee, filed the lawsuit on behalf of Kness.

On Thursday, Banks characterized the assault as "unprovoked and an over-reaction that left my client permanently disfigured."

Kness immediately sought emergency care for the nine-inch laceration that required 39 stitches.

The incident left Kness with a "severe and permanent scar," the lawsuit states. The assault resulted in the development of keloided/hypertrophied scarring.

"I think once he realized that he was always going to have the scar and it dwelled on him, it's quite a sacrifice," Banks said of the decision to file the lawsuit. "He sought all the medical attention he can and sought the maximum received and it still remains. He and I agree that there is damage here that someone needs to be accountable for."

Banks said Kness did not file a police report following the incident because he and other guests did not want "to cause any trouble."

The lawsuit was not brought up during the spring campaign for the Iowa House seat.

He will face Democrat in the November general election.

Early this year, Highfill him to drop out of the race in exchange for a job. The Iowa House Ethics Committee dismissed the allegation.

Banks said the lawsuit was filed before Highfill announced his candidacy in January.

"In regards to my representation of Mr. Kness, (Highfill's) running for office has no bearing on what we are trying to accomplish," he said.

Greg Hauenstein June 29, 2012 at 05:35 PM
Jake has some explaining to do ASAP. Why bring a shotgun to a college party where alcohol is (presumably with the glass bottle) present??
Jeff Klinzman June 29, 2012 at 05:37 PM
Great. Is THIS the kind of candidate TEA-faction Republicans support, someone who is violent and armed to boot!?
Deb Belt (Editor) June 29, 2012 at 05:49 PM
Should Highfill have disclosed this lawsuit before seeking public office?
Greg Hauenstein June 29, 2012 at 06:09 PM
Absolutely. If elected, he'll be missing work to attend his trial. It's a cliche line in American politics but what else is Jake hiding?
Malachi Waynesboro June 29, 2012 at 08:13 PM
Cream of the GOP
William Eib June 29, 2012 at 08:34 PM
Your average American Teahadist. Armed, dangerous.and brainless.
Jeff Klinzman June 29, 2012 at 10:34 PM
The Iowa GOP does not have to respect the standard of proof, "guilty beyond a reasonable doubt," of criminal law. The Iowa GOP owes the people of this state an investigation and, if they discover there is reason to believe that Jake Highfill assaulted Carson Kness, withhold state party support from Highfill, should he not choose to do the right thing by withdrawing from the election.
Dora Glasberg June 30, 2012 at 12:55 AM
Republicans are very sick people
Dora Glasberg June 30, 2012 at 12:56 AM
Cream of the crap
Barb Nelson June 30, 2012 at 04:56 PM
Wow. Thanks. I WON'T be voting for him AND I am a Republican. Go figure.
M Williams June 30, 2012 at 05:13 PM
(1/2) Political contests have long been the primary venue in which an over-eager media and a naïve constituency conspire to create an environment which apparently places sensationalism above fact-checking and accuracy in reporting. My intention is not so much to defend Highfill but more to defend the fundamental ideals of American justice that seem to be alarmingly absent from this discussion. In the two articles published thus far, we’ve talked only of allegations – with no obvious effort on anyone’s part to get at the facts of the story. This is a lawsuit, not a criminal case (in fact, no police report exists for the alleged incident). This has several important implications: (1) No criminal charges were levied at the time of the dispute; (2) Having failed to file a police report, Kness then waited over a year to initiate any sort of legal action; (3) The only possible aim of civil litigation is monetary compensation - thus it is certain that both “damages” and Kness’ account of the incident were skewed for this purpose; (4) This being an ongoing case, any right-minded attorney has already advised Highfill not to comment.
M Williams June 30, 2012 at 05:13 PM
(2/2) These are just a couple points, but they exemplify the alarming tendency to jump to conclusions before the facts are on the table. To anyone who already assumes the legitimacy of these allegations, I see such rash judgment as fundamentally and importantly irresponsible. The last thing we want is a political and social climate in which fundamental American values – like the equation of truth and justice, or the presumption of innocence unless guilt is proven – have been abandoned in favor of playing in the mud.
Maria Houser Conzemius June 30, 2012 at 06:41 PM
Kinda reminds me of Mitt Romney's bullying and assault of a classmate. Remember when he chased, held down, and cut a long-haired classmate's hair by force? At least Romney didn't disfigure anyone for life, although I'm sure he left emotional scars.
Aliceandthe Catt July 02, 2012 at 02:47 AM
All GOP are evil and should be extracted from America before it ti too late....
Greg Hauenstein July 02, 2012 at 01:48 PM
That's not right.
jim james November 07, 2012 at 05:18 AM
Find out the details before making assumptions people. Kness has a history of provoking poeple, physically attacking them, or attempting to physically harm them. He has done so to me, my cousin, and many other people I know in and outside of the Johnston community. In no case has the outcome been in Kness's favor.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something